Fernandina Beach's new City Commission took office Tuesday evening with newly elected Commissioner Scott Inglis calling for greater public participation and a review of city spending as the commission prepares for millions of dollars in potential property tax revenue losses.
City Clerk Caroline Best administered the oath of office to Mayor Genece Minshew, Vice Mayor Tim Poynter and Commissioners Darron Ayscue and Inglis during Tuesday's organizational meeting at City Hall.
The new commission also includes Joyce Tuten, whose term continues through 2028. Minshew succeeds James Antun as mayor, while Poynter replaces Ayscue as vice mayor.
Inglis, a 35-year Fernandina Beach resident serving his first term, said his campaign revealed widespread concerns among residents who believe city government is not listening to them.
"Throughout my campaign, there was one concern that kept coming up: people felt they weren't being heard," Inglis said. "Public participation should be more than 3 minutes at a microphone; it should be an opportunity to make a difference."
Inglis said he never expected to seek public office and thanked his wife, Lisa, for her support.
"I did not run for office for a title or a political career; I ran because I care about this town and the people who call it home," he said.
He also addressed the city's financial outlook following voter approval of Amendment 3, which expands Florida's homestead property tax exemption.
"We have some difficult financial decisions ahead, especially following the passage of Amendment 3," Inglis said. "We will need to take a hard look at our priorities, question our expenses, and find better ways to operate without losing sight of the people we serve."
City Manager Sarah Campbell previously estimated that Amendment 3 could reduce the city's annual property tax collections by approximately $3.3 million once the expanded exemption is fully implemented in 2028.
The estimate, based on 2025 property values, represents a potential 15.6% reduction in property tax revenue. The actual loss will depend on future property assessments and tax rates.
The amendment increases the homestead exemption for non-school property taxes to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028.
Inglis said disagreements among commissioners should not prevent them from working together.
"Different perspectives can lead to better decisions when we're willing to work together," he said.
He promised residents he would ask questions, research issues, listen with an open mind and remain accountable for his decisions.
Mayor Minshew, in her remarks, focused on cooperation, respect and the importance of maintaining civil debate at City Hall.
"We won't always agree on every issue, and that's okay," Minshew said. "Healthy debate and different perspectives are part of good government."
She said the commission's conduct toward residents and one another matters as much as its policy decisions.
"But how we treat one another, how we listen, and how we work together matter just as much as the decisions that we make," she said.
"As mayor, I want to help foster a spirit of respect, cooperation, and shared purpose, both on this commission and throughout our community."
Minshew said she hopes commissioners will concentrate on their common responsibilities rather than their disagreements.
"We have important work ahead of us, and I believe we do our best work when we focus on what brings us together rather than what divides us," she said.
Vice Mayor Poynter congratulated Minshew on becoming mayor and welcomed Inglis to the commission. He also thanked his family for supporting his public service.
"You can't get through this without a strong family," Poynter said.
The organizational meeting also included scheduled recognition of outgoing Mayor Antun, whose four years of commission service began in December 2022.
Minshew ended her remarks with a brief message to her colleagues.
"Now let's get to work."
1 comment on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here
JoeW
"...the importance of maintaining civil debate at City Hall. ...". Let's just wait to hear what our distinguished resident Mr Timothy Poytner has to say about this?
2 hours ago Report this